Hill v. State — conviction affirmed without a written opinion
Case Delvrin Jamal Hill v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge Rowe (Charlie Crist, 2009); […]
Uncategorized
Criminal
Uncategorized
Maddox v. State — First District affirmed without a written opinion
Case Jacob J. Maddox v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge LEWIS (Jeb Bush, 2001);
Uncategorized
Williams v. State — Conviction or sentence affirmed without explanation
Case Reamon Williams v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge KELSEY (Rick Scott, 2015); M.K.
Uncategorized
Nash v. Florida — Trial court failed to orally pronounce urinalysis cost requirement at sentencing; reversed that probation condition
Case Suavae Orion Nash v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge Ray (Rick Scott, 2011);
Uncategorized
Taylor v. Florida — Habeas corpus petition dismissed
Case Anthony C. Taylor v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge Rowe (Charlie Crist, 2009);
Uncategorized
McNeill v. State of Florida — Habeas corpus petition dismissed
Case Marlon W. McNeill v. State of Florida, Attorney General, Chief Inspector General Court Florida First District Court of Appeal
Uncategorized
Crawford v. State of Florida — Affirmed convictions for interference with child custody and witness tampering; excluded custody evidence deemed harmless error; juror interview motions require sworn allegations and timely filing
Case Crawford v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge LEWIS (Jeb Bush, 2001) Date Decided
Uncategorized
Clark v. Florida — Reverses conviction where trial court failed to hold competency hearing despite competing expert reports
Case James Clark III v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge OSTERHAUS (Rick Scott, 2013);
Uncategorized
Kennedy v. Comerford — Appeals court upholds consecutive sentencing under Florida’s statutory default rule
Case Kennedy v. Comerford, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge OSTERHAUS (Rick Scott,
Uncategorized
Robertson v. State of Florida — Court dismisses pro se petition filed by defendant already represented by counsel
Case Mark Robertson v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge ROBERTS (Charlie Crist, 2007); KELSEY
Uncategorized
McNeill v. Florida — Habeas corpus petition dismissed
Case Marlon W. McNeill v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge ROBERTS (Charlie Crist, 2007);
Uncategorized
Mathis v. Comerford — Florida appeals court dismisses habeas corpus petition
Case Mathis v. Comerford, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge Bilbrey (Rick Scott,
Uncategorized
Miller v. State of Florida — Habeas petition dismissed pursuant to Moultrie precedent
Case Micheal Devon Miller v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge LEWIS (Jeb Bush, 2001);
Uncategorized
Moore v. Florida — Reversed double jeopardy convictions for two burglary counts; affirmed remaining conviction and sentence
Case Moore v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge ROBERTS (Charlie Crist, 2007); WINOKUR (Rick
Uncategorized
Shinault v. Florida — Affirmed: Trial court’s omission of written dangerousness finding during probation revocation held harmless error
Case Rachel E. Shinault v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge Treadwell (Ron DeSantis, 2025)
Uncategorized
Aitken v. Quinn — Appellate court denies mandamus where circuit court is already addressing habeas petition
Case Steven M. Aitken v. R. Quinn, Warden of Santa Rosa Correctional Inst. Court Florida First District Court of Appeal
Uncategorized
Murphy v. Florida — Affirmed first degree murder conviction based on sufficient circumstantial evidence
Case William Walter Murphy, III v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge OSTERHAUS (Rick Scott,
Uncategorized
Adelson v. State — Affirmed conviction; pretrial publicity alone insufficient for change of venue
Case Charles Adelson v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge Rowe (Charlie Crist, 2009) Date
Uncategorized
Linder v. Florida Commission on Offender Review — Court affirmed that challenging conditional release supervision eligibility is not a collateral criminal proceeding exempt from filing fee liens
Case John Linder v. Florida Commission on Offender Review Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge Ray (Rick Scott,
Uncategorized
Watts v. Florida — Affirmed; trial court may determine violent felony offender status without jury at probation violation sentencing
Case Watts v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge Ray (Rick Scott, 2011); WINOKUR (Rick
Uncategorized
Young v. Register, Ford — Court dismissed petition because petitioner attempted to represent himself while already represented by counsel
Case Douglas James Young Jr. v. Timothy Register, Tommy Ford, Department of Children and Family, Shane Vann, State of Florida,
Uncategorized
Dare v. State of Florida — Habeas petition dismissed without explanation
Case Dare v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge Bilbrey (Rick Scott, 2014); NORDBY (Ron
Uncategorized
Adams v. State of Florida — Habeas petition dismissed without substantive review
Case Eric Leonard Adams v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge KELSEY (Rick Scott, 2015);
Uncategorized
Young v. State of Florida — Court dismisses pro se petition from defendant represented by counsel
Case Douglas James Young, Jr. v. State of Florida Court Florida First District Court of Appeal Judge LEWIS (Jeb Bush,